Huppert’s call to end strip searches of children rejected

22 June, 2012 1 Comment

June 22, 2012

A call by Cambridge MP, Julian Huppert to stop the police having the power to strip search children without an adult present has been rejected by Home Office Minister, Nick Herbert.

He told Julian that, although he was aware of the arguments in favour of raising the age to 18, there are a number of reasons against changing the law. But he did agree to keep the matter under review.

Julian originally raised the question about police searches in youth custody twice with Mr Herbert, Minister for Policing and Criminal Justice in Parliament after concerns from a resident.

The Parliamentary session ran out of time, however, before a reply could be given and so Mr Herbert replied personally in writing to Julian.

He said: “I am aware of the arguments that organisations such as the Howard League for Penal Reform and others have made in favour of raising the age at which an individual becomes an adult under PACE (Police and Criminal Evidence Act). However, there are also a number of reasons against changing the law.

“Having carefully weighed up the issues, I have decided that it would not be appropriate to amend the law in this area at the present time. I will, however, keep this matter under review.”

Julian said: “I believe it is totally wrong to have contradictory laws which, on the one hand class children as adults when they reach 18 yet give police the power to carry out invasive searches on those under 18 in youth custody.

“There can be no justification for this type of action without an adult present and my view is shared by others. I am disappointed that Mr Herbert does not see it that way. But I will continue to press for change so that our children can be protected under the law when they are at their most vulnerable.”

Leave a comment

  • Paul SUllivan: February 3, 2014 4:35 pm

    Julian; female prisoners were routinely strip searched until this was stopped about a year ago. If it could be stopped then one could question what its purpose was in the first place. Similarly, juveniles in Secure Training Centres (and, indeed, Secure Children’s Homes) were also routinely strip searched until this was scaled back recently, so again, one can question why it was needed in the first place. Children and young people do not have the confidence or ‘power’ to challenge such actions (as adult in prison can). I would suggest that most strip searching is done for one of two reasons: 1) to provide the searchers with a sense of power in degrading and humiliating the victim of the search; 2) to deliberately degrade and humiliate a person to gain control and authority. Such searches rarely proffer any real results or finds and far more effective methods such as ‘BOSS Chair’ and other detectors are available.

Inappropriate and irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin’s discretion. Your email is used for verification purposes only, it will never be shared.